An interesting question was just posed to me while I was browsing a kink meme for Thor…
…the problem at hand was an abandoned fic. The author had ceased writing their story and had completely disappeared, no word on if they wished to continue the story and unable to be located as they were anon.
Another author, enamored with the original story and upset that it had been abandoned, asked if anyone would be mind if they took up the story in the original author’s stead and finished it themselves, so as to give the story a conclusion.
(The rest under a ‘cut’ because, damn this got long.)
Hi! I hope you don’t mind me throwing out my (really long) two cents because this got me thinking.
On one hand I think you’re right and that a fanfiction author (or moderator) has to be pretty damn hypocritical to refuse other fanfiction writers to write things based off or inspired by their story. On the other hand. Fandom is an iffy place with no real rules. We have to tread carefully and be respectful (if we want fandom to be a good place that is. I know there is lots of wank, but that wank happens exactly because people aren’t careful and respectful). With an anon author who can’t be reached and a fic that isn’t finished… It’s hard to to think of a way to be respectful to the first author’s work when you can’t getting their opinion or consent. Especially in a work that is not finished because then it’s not an alternate ending fanfiction type scenario but almost is more of a hijacking I’ll finish it for you.
I don’t know. I think disallowing fanfiction of fanfiction is extremely hypocritical, but in a place where there are no copyright protection or anything except general guidelines and respect I think erring on the side of caution when you can’t even talk to the author isn’t a bad thing?
TL;DR: On it’s face the decision is hypocritical, but not unreasonable because fandom especially has to PLAY NICELY with each other.

